LeftieBiker said:
We have Hx and SOH measurements for the older packs. We don't have records of the different measure of internal resistance you seek. It seems of little value to measure the oranges in the 40kwh packs and then compare them to the apples in the older packs.
You're missing the key point. Yes, it's has become apparent that a high percentage of the 30kWhr batteries have a higher rate of degradation.
That most understand and agree on. Most likely some specific parameter about the battery can account for this difference, e.g. potentially
higher internal resistance resulting on average a
higher battery temperature during use. If that's the case and the 40kWhr batteries also
exhibit a higher internal battery resistance, then the 40kWhr batteries may also have a higher degradation rate. If so, both of the later
batteries may have necessitated the use of TMS more than the earlier batteries. All we need is some sample data from the 30 & 40
batteries. Based on reviewing Hx values posted, it's doubtful that it represents the battery's internal resistance, other than another
measure of lost capacity.
Here're my data from my '13.
11/20/14 -13,700 miles, 76 mohms per LeafDD, 20 Deg, 73% SOC
11/27 -13,800 miles, 67 mohms per LeafDD, 25 deg, 63% SOC
11/30 - 13,900 miles, 56 mohms per LeafDD, 27 deg, 71% SOC
12/2 - 14.100 miles, 55 mohms per LeafDD, 28 deg, 67% SOC
12/16 - 14,500 miles, 89 mohms per LeafDD, 15 deg, 93% SOC
12/27/14 - 14,800 miles, 103 mohms per LeafDD, 11 deg, 24% SOC
3/10 - 17,400 miles, 60 mohms per LeafDD, 30 deg, 73% SOC
3/14 - 17, 550 miles, 56 mohms per LeafDD, 32 deg, 47% SOC
4/14 - 19,100 miles, 59 mohms per LeafDD, 25 deg. 38% SOC
5/4 - 19,989 miles, 64 mohms per LeafDD, 24 deg. 48% SOC
5/15 - 20,400 miles, 73 mohms per LeafDD, 20 deg. 41% SOC
5/22 - 20,700 miles, 58 mohms per LeafDD, 28 deg. 50% SOC
12/10/15 - 28,000 miles, 90 mohms per LeafDD, 19 deg. 92% SOC
4/5 - 32,000 miles, 74 mohms per LeafDD, 24 deg, 55% SOC
5/16 - 33,700 miles,89 mohms per LeafDD, 22 deg, 47% SOC
5/16 - 33.700 miles, 58 mohms per LeafDD, 31 deg, 76% SOC
10/5 - 39,300 miles, 100 mohms per LeafDD, 22 deg, 50% SOC
10/6 - 39,400 miles, 61 mohms per LeafDD, 30 deg, 51% SOC
10/7 - 39,500 miles, 80 mohms per LeafDD, 25 deg, 56% SOC
10/15 - 40,000 miles, 71 mohms per LeafDD, 27 deg, 45% SOC
10/30 - 41,000 miles, 74 mohms per LeafDD, 23 deg, 66% SOC
12/26/16 - 43,000 miles, 110 mohms per LeafDD, 13 deg, 77% SOC
6/10/17 - 49,600 miles, 89 mohms per LeafDD, 19 deg, 70% SOC
Sorry this discussion resulted in being in this thread. The question for this thread relates to whether LeafSpy actually
provides a direct measurement of battery resistance, i.e. delta V / delta I.