palmermd
Posts: 2565
Joined: Fri Apr 23, 2010 3:19 pm
Delivery Date: 31 Mar 2011
Leaf Number: 1100011011
Location: Hermosa Beach, CA

Re: EV's Too Quiet ?!

Fri Dec 17, 2010 2:30 pm

Hybrids have been on the road for more than 10 years, and there is not one case of a blind pedestrian getting hit by one. I can't find the link right now, but there was a study done. As Gary said, if this is a problem, then there should be a minimum sound level for all vehicles, not just hybrids and EV's.
Michael

Leaf from 31 March 2011 - Traded 18 April 2018 for Tesla Model 3 Unicorn
Driving electric since 1996


Leaf Bar Loss

User avatar
TRONZ
Posts: 2240
Joined: Tue Sep 21, 2010 11:01 pm
Delivery Date: 31 Jan 2011
Leaf Number: 202
Location: Denver, CO

Re: EV's Too Quiet ?!

Fri Dec 17, 2010 2:41 pm

Spies wrote:Another concern I have about where all this is going is when some pedestrian does get injured as the result of being hit by an EV or hybrid its not going to be the pedestrian or drivers fault but the fault of the manufacturer or the government for lack of noise makers on older EV and hybrid cars and or not being loud enough noise makers on the ones that have them. Seems like prime lawsuit material to me. I really hope I am wrong about this.


IMHO - That is why you do NOT want a legal mandate forcing older Hybrids to a "New Industry Standard." Lawyers love to use these sorts of phrases to create thresholds of negligence. They should just do the right thing moving forward from 2011. A smart manufacturer would just make the sound like a background app. Make it a purely digital issue. The sound and features (on/off) are just updated wirelessly by Carwings to meet whatever the latest greatest law of the month is. Simple, cost effective and future proof.
Every start, is as good as any start can ever be. - Douglas Darden

Stats;
2011 LEAF SL VIN#202, Delivered 01.30.11. Now, by far, the oldest LEAF in Colorado.

Yodrak
Posts: 492
Joined: Thu Jun 17, 2010 7:01 am
Delivery Date: 12 Mar 2015
Leaf Number: 402954
Location: St Louis, MO

Re: EV's Too Quiet ?!

Wed Dec 29, 2010 10:27 am

When completely oblivious people are inconsiderate enough to walk in the center of a parking lot lane I have no reservations about being inconsiderate enough to blow the horn at them.

I agree that people who blow their horn outside someone's house to notify the whole neighborhood of their arrival should have a car bomb wired to the horn circuit.

mwalsh wrote:I've been behind someone walking up the center of a parking lot a few times where it's taken a little blip of the throttle to let them know you're behind them. Of course you could "bip" your horn at them too, but that can give them a bit of a fright if they happen to be completely oblivious.
Khun Yodrak
2013 SL

Yodrak
Posts: 492
Joined: Thu Jun 17, 2010 7:01 am
Delivery Date: 12 Mar 2015
Leaf Number: 402954
Location: St Louis, MO

Re: EV's Too Quiet ?!

Wed Dec 29, 2010 10:44 am

I pretty much agree with you. I myself was recently startled when walking through my company's parking lot when a Prius came up and passed me from behind - I had no idea it was there until the front end had passed me and I saw it with my peripheral vision.

Pretty much all forms of animal life, we humans among them, scan for danger, including car danger, with our ears as well as our eyes. There is a reason why we have 5 senses that we can use for detection - sometimes 1, or 2, or 3, or even 4 are not enough depending on the circumstances. I vote that we keep the redundancy.

TRONZ wrote:Until enough EV's get out on the roads, it is hard to make a meaningful, informed policy. The only data we have so far are Hybrids in parking lots. I will admit to having been stunned at seeing a Prius on the heels of my kids without them even knowing the car was there. We have just all been conditioned to scan for car dangers with our ears and eyes. Our roadways will get quieter and we will adapt to mostly visual scanning over time. Till then I say do what needs to be done to save lives. If one child's life is saved because of these noise devices, then I say it is well worth it.
Khun Yodrak
2013 SL

xRB
Posts: 42
Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2010 4:24 am

Re: EV's Too Quiet ?!

Wed Dec 29, 2010 12:41 pm

Yodrak wrote:I pretty much agree with you. I myself was recently startled when walking through my company's parking lot when a Prius came up and passed me from behind - I had no idea it was there until the front end had passed me and I saw it with my peripheral vision.

Pretty much all forms of animal life, we humans among them, scan for danger, including car danger, with our ears as well as our eyes. There is a reason why we have 5 senses that we can use for detection - sometimes 1, or 2, or 3, or even 4 are not enough depending on the circumstances. I vote that we keep the redundancy.

TRONZ wrote:Until enough EV's get out on the roads, it is hard to make a meaningful, informed policy. The only data we have so far are Hybrids in parking lots. I will admit to having been stunned at seeing a Prius on the heels of my kids without them even knowing the car was there. We have just all been conditioned to scan for car dangers with our ears and eyes. Our roadways will get quieter and we will adapt to mostly visual scanning over time. Till then I say do what needs to be done to save lives. If one child's life is saved because of these noise devices, then I say it is well worth it.


The people who will write the final "EVs must be noisy" regulation are the group that brought us the "beep beep beep" made by trucks backing up --- a loud and obnoxious sound, one that unfortunately you quickly learn to entirely tune out.

Kenneth
Posts: 13
Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2011 11:22 am

Re: EV's Too Quiet ?!

Tue Apr 12, 2011 5:19 pm

I would just like to know a few things about the fake-noise speaker located in the left wheel well. Is it possible to disconnect this or cut a wire? Has any Leaf owner actually done this yet and did it work? Did it cause any problems such as a light coming on? :evil:

JasonT
Posts: 509
Joined: Sun Apr 25, 2010 8:42 am
Location: AZ

Re: EV's Too Quiet ?!

Tue Apr 12, 2011 8:21 pm

Kenneth wrote:I would just like to know a few things about the fake-noise speaker located in the left wheel well.
Before you go disabling speakers (which has been mentioned elsewhere, I honestly can't remember what the conclusion was on it), you might want to look at what the clever folks here have come up with at viewtopic.php?f=37&t=3296

This way you can still make the noise if desired (I can see some cases where the backup beep might be nice), but by default the car won't make additional noise.

Kenneth
Posts: 13
Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2011 11:22 am

Re: EV's Too Quiet ?!

Wed Apr 13, 2011 7:16 pm

Accessing the wheel well speaker and simply unplugging it sounds doable. I doubt I would do what some Leaf owners have done with those seemingly highly technical "fixes". I'll just have to wait until the Leaf arrives which by the way is tomorrow, rescheduled to next week. Dealer says all 600 Leafs sitting in Long Beach have ;to be reprogrammed for something. I have no idea.

Pipcecil
Posts: 810
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2011 4:15 pm
Location: Midlothian, TX

Re: EV's Too Quiet ?!

Fri May 06, 2011 11:27 am

As a noise specialist for roadway noise and mitigation it is a real problem. Its amazing how many roadways are exceeding what is considered an accetable level of vehicular noise. Unfortunately mitigation can't be proposed unless significant work is being done on a roadway (i.e. adding additional lanes of travel). Roadway traffic noise always increases with speed and the faster the acceleration the greater the noise. Areas such as stoplights, toll gantries, etc. are huge spots for noise as well as high speed sections.

Roadway nosie comes from three sources on the car. The tires on the pavement, engines, the smoke stacks from heavy trucks. Obviously with EV's the engine noise is almost non-existant, but the tire noise will still be there. I disagree with adding any additional noise to EV's. We spend so much money to try and reduce noise impacts from roadways I can't fathom why we would try and not do everything to make it worse. Granted a little noise is far less than any ICE engine, but we are adding noise to system that could be quite. Noise mitigation cost millions of dollars a year in sound walls along roadways, we don't need to continue this if possible.

I will conceed that a noise at lower speeds that turns off at higher speeds isn't as great of an inpact as adding a noise all the time to the vehicle, but as many have pointed out, there hasn't been much documentation of blind people getting hit by priuses or other vehicles able to operate on battery alone.

Anyways, if people have specific question on roadway noise impacts and how stuff like that is done, I can answer it all. I do do some airplane and train noise anayses impacts too, but I am siginificantly better at roadway noise.
DFW Public EV Station Locations
DFW Public Charging Access
Plug-In Vehicles Available in Texas
Total Locations: 254
Total EVSEs: 611
Level 1: 66 Level 2: 512 DC Fast: 33

AndyH
Posts: 6388
Joined: Fri Apr 23, 2010 3:43 pm
Location: San Antonio

Re: EV's Too Quiet ?!

Fri May 06, 2011 2:03 pm

While I certainly like my quite quiet EV, I'm not concerned about the noise makes add-on, because it's only on when the vehicle is very slow.

Only the tire noise will contribute to the high-speed din - for a net reduction compared with any other vehicle in that space at that time.

And the noise, when it is active, will be useful to a pedestrian if there are few vehicles in the intersection, but will be lost in the din of the engines and exhausts of other vehicles.

So no - I think it's a severe over reaction to suggest that the currently optional warning sound will harm the pristine soundscape under any conditions... :roll:

Return to “Engineering”