Leaf revival

My Nissan Leaf Forum

Help Support My Nissan Leaf Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Marktm

Well-known member
Leaf Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2016
Messages
854
Location
Houston, TX
I see many 2011/2012/2013 Leafs that are such a bargain here in Houston, TX - especially those with low bars (7 or less). I was extremely lucky to have purchased a like new 2012 SL two years ago that Nissan efficiently and graciously replaced the traction battery a year and 4 months ago - for free (Lizard). The car is so great to drive, but is suffering the same fate of battery fatigue quite quickly. At 36,000 miles, it is yet like a new car in most respects. I'm wondering what my options are over the next couple of years:
1. Negotiate with Nissan for a clean replacement? Like old cell phones, will the old model batteries still be good?
https://www.greencarreports.com/new...tric-car-battery-replacement-and-what-it-took
2. Will a battery rebuild industry exist (sort of like the Prius) that makes economic sense? This is doubt because simply too few exist.
3. Can a 30 KWH battery swap industry start? Seems doubtful - how many of these batteries have actually been made?
4. Give it up for scrap and buy a new one? Most of these older Leafs are still excellent vehicles in all respects except the battery - what a shame.
5. A DIY project :cry: is just not for me.
 
There already is a battery rebuild/reconditioning industry, see https://www.evhybridshop.com/battery-conditioning as an example, they have shops all over the place.

The real question to ask is why the battery is degrading so quickly.
 
cmwade77 said:
There already is a battery rebuild/reconditioning industry, see https://www.evhybridshop.com/battery-conditioning as an example, they have shops all over the place.

Are they legit business?
 
soldcake said:
cmwade77 said:
There already is a battery rebuild/reconditioning industry, see https://www.evhybridshop.com/battery-conditioning as an example, they have shops all over the place.

Are they legit business?
Yes, but each shop is individually owned so the quality of service will vary. Basically, it is a network of independent shops that all specialize in Hybrid and Electric Vehicles. Think kind of like looking for a AAA approved repair shop, but for electric vehicles.
 
cmwade77 said:
There already is a battery rebuild/reconditioning industry, see https://www.evhybridshop.com/battery-conditioning as an example, they have shops all over the place.

The real question to ask is why the battery is degrading so quickly.

Here in Houston there are a number of Prius Hybrid replacement shops - have never seen a Leaf replacement offered - anyone know of such?
 
I am in a similar situation (warranty battery replacement), but original owner of the car (with more miles).
While the replacement (Lizard) battery is doing a bit better than the original, I know that day will come when I need to make the same decision: replace or move on. At that time, I believe I will either:
1) Have Nissan replace the battery (at my cost)
2) Trade it in on another EV (Leaf 2.0?)
At this time, I still believe that only Nissan can both obtain a (new) battery pack and reliably "mate" it to the car.
 
As a money question, I would just calculate pennies per mile.
$6000/40k miles works out to 15 cents a mile.

That is a pretty reasonable cap cost to run a car, so the real question is whether the car fulfills the owner's drive requirements.
The economics pencil out much nicer with PV :)
 
SageBrush said:
As a money question, I would just calculate pennies per mile.
$6000/40k miles works out to 15 cents a mile.

That is a pretty reasonable cap cost to run a car, so the real question is whether the car fulfills the owner's drive requirements.
The economics pencil out much nicer with PV :)
Yeah, but you should get at least 60,000 out of a new battery, after all that is the capacity warranty on them and if you purchase a new battery, it comes with a new warranty, so it really should be $0.10. That being said if you buy a new battery, then it drops below the threshold within the warranty you will get another battery, so you could end up getting near 120,000 miles on the $6,000 investment if you do it right.
 
cmwade77 said:
SageBrush said:
As a money question, I would just calculate pennies per mile.
$6000/40k miles works out to 15 cents a mile.

That is a pretty reasonable cap cost to run a car, so the real question is whether the car fulfills the owner's drive requirements.
The economics pencil out much nicer with PV :)
Yeah, but you should get at least 60,000 out of a new battery, after all that is the capacity warranty on them and if you purchase a new battery, it comes with a new warranty, so it really should be $0.10. That being said if you buy a new battery, then it drops below the threshold within the warranty you will get another battery, so you could end up getting near 120,000 miles on the $6,000 investment if you do it right.
The warranty is 60k miles/5yrs, whichever comes first.

It is a rare 24 kWh LEAF owner who reaches the mile limit before the time limit.
5 years * 8000m/yr = 40k miles

Take a look at the posts of people who have taken advantage of the warranty and keep in mind that Nissan has planned the warranty to just last long enough, meaning the battery capacity drops to below 9 bars just after warranty lapse. A few "lucky" owners get replacement batteries, the remainder post threads like this one or dump the car as a failed, expensive exercise.
 
My 2017 has the longer warranty. I'm sure it will satisfy my needs even at 8 bars but still.....something about this whole affair just doesn't sit right with me.

But on the other hand, I just chatted with a co-worker who has done the third maintenance item on his Leaf after 40k miles: he replaced the wipers. The first 2 were new tires and washer fluid.

If my Leaf does as well I will consider it a win. I do all the maintenance on my ICE cars and it adds up. If I had to pay someone to do it, it would be terrible. I also get to charge free at work currently so while that is small $ it is also nice. Currently at 92% SOH according to LeafSpy at 4k miles. However, the car started at 95% as far as I can tell and still shows 120m range on a full charge (I live in CO and drive the speed limit :mrgreen: ) . I'm curious to see how things end up after the next summer.
 
SageBrush said:
cmwade77 said:
SageBrush said:
As a money question, I would just calculate pennies per mile.
$6000/40k miles works out to 15 cents a mile.

That is a pretty reasonable cap cost to run a car, so the real question is whether the car fulfills the owner's drive requirements.
The economics pencil out much nicer with PV :)
Yeah, but you should get at least 60,000 out of a new battery, after all that is the capacity warranty on them and if you purchase a new battery, it comes with a new warranty, so it really should be $0.10. That being said if you buy a new battery, then it drops below the threshold within the warranty you will get another battery, so you could end up getting near 120,000 miles on the $6,000 investment if you do it right.
The warranty is 60k miles/5yrs, whichever comes first.

It is a rare 24 kWh LEAF owner who reaches the mile limit before the time limit.
5 years * 8000m/yr = 40k miles

Take a look at the posts of people who have taken advantage of the warranty and keep in mind that Nissan has planned the warranty to just last long enough, meaning the battery capacity drops to below 9 bars just after warranty lapse. A few "lucky" owners get replacement batteries, the remainder post threads like this one or dump the car as a failed, expensive exercise.
I bought my car used, so I have no idea what the previous owner had done, but I got it with 9 bars and it dropped to 8 in December, quite literraly 3 months before the the warranty was up. I was willing to risk it because i got a good enough deak tgat even if i had to replace the batter at my expense, it would have been fine. But i lucked out and got a free replacement. I monitor my batterys health with Leafspy and when the battery was first installed, the SOH went up about .5% and it stabilized and hasn't moved in either direction since then, although I will admit that I don't understand how the SOH can be about 102%, I would have thought 100% would be the max.

And there are people who only drive 8,000 miles a year? I do a minimum of about 18,000 miles a year, so I wonder what difference that is going to make long term on the battery. Yes, I really drive my leaf at lease 1,500 per month.
 
cmwade77 said:
And there are people who only drive 8,000 miles a year?
My mother's 07 Altima Hybrid (bought as a leftover 07 around Feb 2008) has under 50K miles on it (maybe not even 45K, will need to check later). If it had 50K, that's only 5K miles/year.

My 06 Prius has barely moved since a '13 Leaf became my primary car end of July 2013. It does WAY less than 8K miles/year now. If my records are right, it has moved under 8K miles since end of July 2013.
 
Crazy, even our CMAX Energy, which is primarily just my wife's car now does around 10,000 miles a year and we are shocked thst it gets driven so little. This is why I can never do a lease, we drive too much for them to be viable.

Again, I am not sure if putting that kind if mileage on the Leaf is easier on the battery or harder on it, time will tell I suppose.
 
And there are people who only drive 8,000 miles a year? I do a minimum of about 18,000 miles a year, so I wonder what difference that is going to make long term on the battery. Yes, I really drive my leaf at lease 1,500 per month.


My last year working I think I drove 8k miles. Since I retired I average about 2k per year. My 2013 SV has less than 19k miles on her.
 
cmwade77 said:
I bought my car used, so I have no idea what the previous owner had done, but I got it with 9 bars and it dropped to 8 in December, quite literraly 3 months before the the warranty was up.
Meaning you ran up against the time limit, not the miles limit.
As I said, typical.
 
SageBrush said:
cmwade77 said:
I bought my car used, so I have no idea what the previous owner had done, but I got it with 9 bars and it dropped to 8 in December, quite literraly 3 months before the the warranty was up.
Meaning you ran up against the time limit, not the miles limit.
As I said, typical.
Actually, I was at about 55,000 miles as well, so both were approaching fast.
 
cmwade77 said:
SageBrush said:
cmwade77 said:
I bought my car used, so I have no idea what the previous owner had done, but I got it with 9 bars and it dropped to 8 in December, quite literraly 3 months before the the warranty was up.
Meaning you ran up against the time limit, not the miles limit.
As I said, typical.
Actually, I was at about 55,000 miles as well, so both were approaching fast.
Ok, but look at thef posts that talk about battery warranty replacement. Time is overwhelmingly the common theme. Why do you think all these threads exist asking how to accelerate degradation ?
 
Evoforce said:
Just remember, if your car is out of warranty, a replacement traction battery comes with only a 12 month/12,000 mile warranty.

According to the information I have read from Nissan, purchasing a new traction battery gets you a new warranty (8 years, 100,000 miles for defects and 5 years, 60,000 miles for capacity).
 
GerryAZ said:
Evoforce said:
Just remember, if your car is out of warranty, a replacement traction battery comes with only a 12 month/12,000 mile warranty.

According to the information I have read from Nissan, purchasing a new traction battery gets you a new warranty (8 years, 100,000 miles for defects and 5 years, 60,000 miles for capacity).
I would very much like to see that warranty. It sure would make the $6k battery cost more palatable.
 
Back
Top