Simply put, mudguards are an aerodynamic hindrance. And of course the faster u go, the more detrimental their effect. I took mine off because they were fugly and and aero issue. I would like a rear wheel arch cover. I could make something stupid out of cardboard and tape it on, but scientifically, due to changing conditions and living in a highly populated area...would be hard to get any remotely scientific data. It is understood by many on the Honda Insight forum (I own an original Honda Insight also) that the rear wheel covers are only good for about 1 maybe 2 mpg at best.