Using rough numbers, I figure that our operating expense - charging and maintenance together - averaged over the year is about 5-6 cents/mile on our Leaf, whereas our Audi is closer to 20-25. That's before registration, insurance and depreciation, and partly due to towing our camper with the Audi.
We average close to 4mi/kWh with the Leaf typically, and pay 11 cents/kWh charging at home overnight. So about 3 cents/mile, add in another couple of pennies for tire wear, and that gets you to 5-6 cents/mile. Since we put better but higher rolling resistant tires on, a bit more actually, but that's still in the ballpark.
Given that we don't drive that far to begin with, the net impact to our budget is negligible either way. Rough figures are close enough. I never expect to drive the Leaf across the country, and we never charge anywhere but at home.
Overall, we drive about 55% of our total yearly miles in the Leaf, which has saved us a bit of wear and tear on our Audi. And saved us a few pennies along the way. When we commute, we take light rail. Also out to the airport when we travel farther afield.
We have solar as well, but also 1:1 net metering. So the opportunity cost of charging negates the savings. It still costs us something to charge the car, as we would otherwise sell that energy. Getting solar was a substantial investment, but it has saved us quite a bit in cash flow now that it's paid for. At some point, they'll end 1:1 net metering no doubt, but it won't matter much to us. We'll just shift to using a higher percentage of our own production.
We really like our Leaf. It's a competent little car, especially how we use it.