abasile said:
mwalsh said:
Honestly, now I'm a Volt owner (first time with GM after having nothing but Fords as my daily drivers for years) I'd personally rather have a Chevy than a Tesla, all else being equal. But that's just me.
Overall the Volt has proven to be quite reliable, while many Model S cars have required service under warranty. On the other hand, Tesla's SuperCharger network is a very strong draw for me. And Tesla has generally made servicing their vehicles about as painless as possible for the customer. So, at the same price point, I'd go for a Tesla.
I agree about the Tesla advantage, I'd love to have a Tesla for the features and quality of product after the shakedown cruise is over.
but as to the Volt, you and I have a different standard for "quite reliable". Take a look at 2013 cars in this list:
for 2013 (lower is better)
99 Tesla Model S
41 Chevrolet Volt
34 Nissan Leaf
5 Toyota Prius
99 Tesla Model S (nice car, they definitely need to slow down and get initial build quality up)
41 Chevrolet Volt (2012 chimes in at 45 so 2013 doesn't look like an outlier)
34 Nissan Leaf (2012 is only 30, and 2011 is only 20 so earlier leafs have better numbers)
5 Toyota Prius (likely this number will go up to more normal Prius repair numbers which range from 13-30 depending on the year)
Lower is better (less repair trips per year per hundred cars). I'd consider the 10-20 range extremely reliable, 21-30 range quite reliable, and 31-50 OK but nothing to brag about, and so on.
Sure the Volt is OK but after driving the Prius as long as I have I don't want to go back to OK, I want to stay with quite/extremely reliable.
http://www.truedelta.com/Nissan-LEAF/reliability-968/vs-Volt-1048" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
http://www.truedelta.com/Chevrolet-Volt/reliability-1048/vs-Prius-272" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
and that list is by no means exhaustive, check out other years or other models if you want to see how something else compares. Just note that the Prius has stayed on the good side of repair history from 2004-2014 and vs that baseline newer Leafs and Volts stand out as having more repairs.
Long term I'm not happy with the Volt having a gas engine and additional cooling system (there have been many cooling system failures in those volt repairs).
I'd bank on the Leaf being more reliable than the Volt long term. The question is will the Bolt ditch the less reliable parts of the Volt or will it keep them?