MT compares “the most innovative car of the (last) century” to the Tesla S.
Motor Trend has taken it upon itself to pit the lauded 2013 Tesla Model S against the venerable 1956 Citroën DS-19 in the magazine's latest Head 2 Head video. In what realm do these two machines cross tracks? Host Jonny Lieberman makes a strong case for the fact that both cars represent the pinnacle of automotive innovation from their respective eras...
http://www.autoblog.com/2013/03/29/tesla-model-s-pitted-against-citroen-ds-19/" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
I was fortunate enough to have a DS as a daily driver for ~ 8 years, and it was certainly the not only the most “innovative” but best all-around car I have ever owned, with the possible exception of my LEAF (ask me again in ~6 more years).
The two main omissions in the comparison, IMO:
The DS, while not cheap, was a true
mass-market car.
When prices are inflation and income adjusted, the DS was roughly comparable to new cars for sale today in the $30,00 to $40,000 price range, Which is why I could afford to buy (and maintain, but only just barely!) a well-used DS in 1980, while I was still in college.
The larger contrast between the two cars, which this review largely missed, is that the DS was a truly radical design, and the form was allowed to follow the function.
It is very unfortunate, IMO, that Tesla chose to try to make the S look like an ICEV.
Maybe the Tesla marketers who dictated the design were right, that the typical ~$100 k car buyer does want a car that looks so much like competing ICEV luxury cars.
The DS is now highly regarded as an innovative car because it’s designers were willing to defy convention in styling as well as engineering, and, it is very unfortunate, IMO, that Tesla was not willing to do the same with the S.
The DS was not only a design success, but a market success as well, and ~1.5 million were sold.
IMO, the design failure by Tesla, is likely to mean it will never approach those sales volumes, nor will it be likely to be remembered in 50 or 60 years as as the most “innovative” vehicle design, of this (half) century.