AndyH
Well-known member
Are you kidding me? Way to grab the words from Rapier's mouth and use them as, well, a rapier.Herm said:Denialist is an ugly word with Holocaust connotations..
Right. I need to believe some blogger that's in the energy business, has a history of less-than-complete facts, and is using a dataset from BP? A dataset that BP considers closed and will not provide to fact checkers? Riiiiight. Do I look like I just fell off the turnip truck?Herm said:Also from Robert Rapier.. we could burn all of Canada and it would not make a dent in the CO2 balance of the world compared to the coal burning emissions from Asia. More on this topic..
One link you included about the 'oil sands'
(see that use of words? Doesn't oil sound nice and normal? Except it's not oil - they're not oil sands - they're TAR SANDS - no, that's not a slur - it's a simple fact with spin removed. The material in the sand is BITUMEN. Ever hear about those dinosaurs trapped in those pits in the LA, CA area? La Brea? Notice those dinosaurs weren't trapped in "The La Brea Oil Pits", they were trapped in the La Brea TAR Pits - because the material was TAR not oil. It was actually bitumen - think asphalt here. Not oil - tar)
starts with an attack on Gasland director Josh Fox - saying he used false information about breast cancer rates in north Texas. It's funny, but I spent some time researching this earlier today and I will tell you that Mr. Rapier is guilty of libel. Why in the world would I think that - especially since that 'fact' has been circulated far and wide in DENIAL circles and mainstream media? Because of this:
http://www.dentonrc.com/local-news/...nes/20110831-breast-cancer-rate-climbs-up.ece
While it's true that cancer rates in the Barnett shale region are at or below the national average, the rate in the rest of Texas is WELL BELOW the national average - and continues to fall even as the rate increases in the shale gas area. Josh Fox factually reported the 'truth on the ground' backed up with CDC data, while pro-gas forces ignore the facts and publish spin.Invasive breast cancer is on the rise in Denton County and five neighboring counties, even as the incidence rate for the disease is lower in the state and falling across the rest of the nation.
According to a 2011 report by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, six counties in the western Dallas-Fort Worth area have the highest rates of invasive breast cancer in Texas.
What Mr. Rapier did was simply repeat the story that fit his overall message - but he didn't publish the facts.
Strike one.
More later.