Here is what I ended up purchasing:
2015 Nissan Leaf SV in Cayenne Red
+Premium Package
+Cargo Cover
+Splash Guards
I paid:
$31,900
less -$3500 NMAC rebate
= $28,400 plus tax (Ohio is 6.75%), title & license (just south of $300 including a $250 doc fee for dealers in Ohio).
I'm looking at a $421.xx/mo payment @ 72mo 0% with $500 down. I'll qualify for the entire $7,500 federal tax credit, so if I were to peanut butter that credit over the entire loan my effective payment is $317.xx.
This is pretty close to a lease payment, and I'll have positive equity after 36 months or less. I think.
The math I did on equity is this: MSRP = $35,010 times .45 (which is the factor they use to calculate residual value for the 36mo leases) = $15,754.50 so if I make the $421 payment for 36mo and additionally contribute the entire $7500 tax rebate to the car I'll owe just $7,697.25 on a car that is presumably worth $15,754.50 giving me just over $8000 in positive equity.
This higher monthly loan payment (compared to a lease payment) is worth it to me so I'm not worrying about the mileage terms of the lease as well as possible fees for damage, etc.